Can You Use Swamp Cooler Ducts for Central Air Conditioning?
A swamp cooler drop is big enough for a 2 to 5 ton AC system, but it is half a duct system. The return, R-8 insulation, 4.0 CFM leakage limit and roof opening that have to change.
Short answer
Partly. The supply drop is more than big enough: a drop built for a 4,500 CFM cooler carries almost four times the 1,200 CFM a 3 ton air conditioner moves. But a cooler system is only half of what AC needs. It has no return duct, it relies on open windows, and its roof jack is one square hole where a packaged unit needs separate supply and return openings. Under the 2021 IECC, any new duct you add must be R-8 in the attic, and the system must leak no more than 4.0 CFM per 100 sq ft when tested.
Key takeaways
- Size is not the problem. At 400 CFM per ton, a 3 ton system pushes 1,200 CFM through a 17-3/4 in cooler drop at about 550 fpm, roughly 40 percent of the speed the cooler itself runs it at.
- The return is the problem. Goodman's air handler manual says the unit is designed for a complete supply and return duct system and must have a return air filter; a cooler house has no return at all.
- The 2021 IECC (New Mexico edition) requires R-8 on supply and return ducts 3 in and larger outside conditioned space, and total leakage of 4.0 CFM per 100 sq ft or less on a post-construction test. For a 1,500 sq ft house that is 60 CFM.
- Ducts newly installed during an alteration must meet those rules; the code text does not require the unaltered parts of an existing system to be upgraded.
- A downflow packaged unit needs two side-by-side openings (13-7/8 x 11-1/2 in supply and 16-7/8 x 11-1/2 in return on a 2 or 3 ton GE NP16GV), not the single 17-3/4 or 19-3/4 in square a cooler jack leaves.
On this page
Partly. The supply drop from a swamp cooler is more than big enough for central air: a drop built for a 4,500 CFM cooler carries almost four times the 1,200 CFM a 3 ton air conditioner moves. But it is only half an AC duct system: there is no return, the air leaves through windows, and new ducts must meet energy code insulation and leakage limits.
Contractor pages say the ducts "may need sealing or replacement" and stop there. Below is what that means in numbers. The opposite question, whether a cooler can run through existing AC ducts, is covered in the ductwork guide.
What a cooler duct system has, and what AC needs
| Item | Swamp cooler system | Central air system |
|---|---|---|
| Airflow | About 2,000 to 5,000 CFM on residential downdrafts (Champion 3000 to 5000 DD: 2,175 to 4,983 CFM at 0 in) | 350 to 450 CFM per ton (Goodman), so 1,050 to 1,350 CFM for 3 tons |
| Supply | One drop through a 13-5/8, 17-3/4 or 19-3/4 in square roof jack, often to one ceiling diffuser | Supply ducts to the rooms, sized by ACCA methods (Goodman refers to Manual D) |
| Return | None | A complete return duct with a filter (Goodman); a "closed return air duct system" (GE) |
| Where air leaves | Open windows or ceiling relief dampers, 1 to 2 sq ft per 1,000 CFM | Back through the return; windows shut |
| Static pressure | Low; a Champion 5000 DD loses 240 to 260 CFM for each added 0.1 in | Ducts sized for no more than 0.5 in (Goodman); GE blower tables run 0 to 0.80 in |
| Attic duct insulation | R-6 to R-8 is common | R-8 on supply and return ducts 3 in and larger outside conditioned space (2021 IECC R403.3.1) |
| Leakage | Open to outdoors through the pads by design | 4.0 CFM per 100 sq ft or less on a post-construction test (R403.3.6) |
Relief area is from venting and relief air, jack openings from the roof jack size chart, and cooler airflow at static pressure from the motor size chart.
Airflow: the drop is oversized, not undersized
Two answers circulate: cooler ducts are useless for AC, or they are already big enough, so just add a condenser. The second has the size right and the conclusion wrong. (Why cooler and AC airflow differ so much is in CFM explained.)
Goodman's air handler manual says the ductwork is "to be sized to accommodate 350-450 CFM per ton of cooling with the static pressure not to exceed 0.5" in w.c.", and its control defaults are "based on 400CFM per ton." GE's NP16GV packaged units set cooling airflow in the same range: the 3 ton model's normal cooling settings run 800 to 1,400 CFM. At 400 CFM per ton, here is how fast that air would move through each cooler drop size:
| AC size | Airflow | 13-5/8 in drop (1.29 sq ft) | 17-3/4 in drop (2.19 sq ft) | 19-3/4 in drop (2.71 sq ft) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 tons | 800 CFM | 620 fpm | 365 fpm | 295 fpm |
| 3 tons | 1,200 CFM | 930 fpm | 550 fpm | 445 fpm |
| 4 tons | 1,600 CFM | 1,240 fpm | 730 fpm | 590 fpm |
| 5 tons | 2,000 CFM | 1,550 fpm | 915 fpm | 740 fpm |
For comparison, the coolers themselves push 1,400 to 1,650 fpm through those same openings at 0.3 in of static pressure. Every AC size in the table runs slower than that through the two common drop sizes; only a 4 or 5 ton system in the small 13-5/8 in drop of a Champion 3000 reaches the cooler's own speed. A drop that carried a cooler's air will carry an air conditioner's.
Worked example: a 4,500 CFM drop and a 3 ton system
The ductwork guide sizes a 4,500 CFM cooler drop at about 3 sq ft (21 x 21 in) for 1,500 fpm. A 3 ton system at 400 CFM per ton moves 1,200 CFM, about a quarter of the cooler's 4,500. Through 3 sq ft it travels at 1,200 / 3 = 400 fpm. Even at Goodman's top figure of 450 CFM per ton (1,350 CFM) it is 450 fpm. The drop has room to spare.
Elevation nudges the number up, not enough to matter here. The Bonneville Power Administration's airflow test notes that systems at elevation need more volumetric flow "since the air is thinner" and puts the bump at "approximately 10%" at 5,000 ft. CaptiveAire's density factor, about 0.82 at Albuquerque's 5,350 ft, makes it closer to 22%, which puts a 3 ton system nearer 1,460 CFM. That is still under 500 fpm through the 3 sq ft drop. The full altitude correction for coolers is in do swamp coolers work at high altitude.
The catch is that a single drop ends at one place. A cooler can blow everything out of one diffuser because open windows pull the air through the rooms. With the windows shut, air reaches only the rooms supply ducts reach, and comes back only through a return.
The return the cooler house does not have
An air conditioner cannot run without a return. Goodman's manual says: "This air handler is designed for a complete supply and return ductwork system," and "Each installation must include a return air filter." GE's packaged unit instructions say "A closed return air duct system shall be used" with return air held between 55 F and 80 F.
That return is new duct carrying the same airflow as the supply, and it has to be real duct: 2021 IECC R403.3.7 says "Building framing cavities shall not be used as ducts or plenums," so a panned-over joist bay or a stud cavity is not a code return.
The cooler's exits have to close too. Ceiling relief dampers that let cooler air into the attic become holes from the conditioned house to the attic; remove and patch them or seal them shut.
Insulation and leakage under the 2021 IECC
From the New Mexico edition of the 2021 IECC. R403.3.1: "Supply and return ducts located outside conditioned space shall be insulated to an R-value of not less than R-8 for ducts 3 inches (76 mm) in diameter and larger," R-6 below that. An attic drop and an attic return are both outside conditioned space. R403.3.4: "Ducts, air handlers and filter boxes shall be sealed." R403.3.5 tests them at 0.1 in w.g. (25 Pa) with the registers taped, and R403.3.6 sets the limits: 4.0 CFM per 100 sq ft of conditioned floor area after construction, or at rough-in with the air handler in place (3.0 without it), and 8.0 where all ducts and the air handler are inside the thermal envelope.
They scale with the house:
| Conditioned floor area | Post-construction or rough-in with air handler (4.0) | Rough-in without air handler (3.0) | All ducts inside envelope (8.0) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,200 sq ft | 48 CFM | 36 CFM | 96 CFM |
| 1,500 sq ft | 60 CFM | 45 CFM | 120 CFM |
| 1,800 sq ft | 72 CFM | 54 CFM | 144 CFM |
| 2,000 sq ft | 80 CFM | 60 CFM | 160 CFM |
A cooler duct is open to the outdoors through the cabinet and pads on purpose; a 17-3/4 in jack is 315 sq in of opening. Before any test can pass, the cooler connection has to be capped or the drop cut off from the old jack, and the drop's seams sealed with mastic or listed tape.
What applies to a conversion, not a new house
Chapter 5 of the same code covers existing homes. R503.1 says alterations must meet the code for new construction "without requiring the unaltered portions of the existing building or building system to comply." R503.1.2 then says "HVAC ducts newly installed, as part of an alteration shall comply with Section R403," with an exception "Where ducts from an existing heating and cooling system are extended."
So the new return, new branches and any replacement drop must meet R-8, sealing and the leakage limits; the text does not require an untouched drop to be redone. How the whole system is tested is settled at the permit; see do you need a permit for a swamp cooler.
Note: New Mexico's amendments name six counties that must comply with the R403.3.5 duct testing rule: San Juan, Sandoval, Santa Fe, Bernalillo, Torrance and Dona Ana. Even there, duct sealing "shall be considered in compliance" when the code official inspects it and the builder or an energy rater verifies it on the state's duct sealing visual inspection checklist.
The roof jack and the new equipment
A cooler jack is one square opening, 13-5/8, 17-3/4 or 19-3/4 in on Champion and MasterCool cabinets. What replaces the cooler on the roof, if anything does, needs two.
| Equipment | Supply opening | Return opening | Roof footprint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Champion 4001 DD cooler | 17-3/4 x 17-3/4 in (315 sq in) | None | 18 in roof jack |
| GE NP16GV, 2 and 3 ton (small base) | 13-7/8 x 11-1/2 in (160 sq in) | 16-7/8 x 11-1/2 in (194 sq in) | Curb 44-3/8 x 44-3/8 in |
| GE NP16GV, 4 and 5 ton (large base) | 19-1/2 x 11-1/2 in (224 sq in) | 19-1/2 x 11-1/2 in (224 sq in) | Curb 44-3/8 x 52-7/8 in |
The cooler's opening is about twice the area of the 3 ton unit's supply collar, but there is only one of it. GE also says duct systems "should be designed for the CFM and static requirements of the job" and "should not be sized by matching the dimensions of the duct connections on the unit." A rooftop unit means a new curb and roof opening, with the old jack opening closed and flashed.
With a split system the condenser sits on the ground and the air handler goes indoors or in the attic; the old drop can become a supply trunk off its plenum, and the jack comes out.
A conversion checklist
B. Carlson, an Albuquerque contractor, says a refrigerated air conversion "can start at just $7,500 for many Albuquerque homes," and lists what raises it: "Leaks or outdated ducts may need sealing or replacement," larger homes may need more capacity or two systems, and "Some homes need panel upgrades." Cooler costs are compared in cost to install a swamp cooler. Here is what "duct upgrades" turns into, in order:
- Get a load calculation. R403.7 requires equipment sized by ACCA Manual S from loads calculated by Manual J.
- Choose packaged or split, and design the return. Ducted, filtered, carrying the full airflow.
- Decide about the drop. Keep it as a supply trunk if it is sound, or replace it at R-8.
- Add supply branches to rooms the single diffuser cannot reach with the windows shut.
- Close every cooler opening. Cap or remove the jack, close the ceiling relief dampers, and seal the old diffuser if it is no longer a supply outlet.
- Seal and test. Mastic or listed tape, then the leakage test or New Mexico's visual checklist.
- Check the electrical service. A cooler circuit is sized for a fractional horsepower motor, as the breaker and wire size guide shows. The compressor is a larger load on its own circuit.
Keeping the cooler for dry months and adding AC for the monsoon is a different job: the systems are isolated with dampers, as in the ductwork guide and swamp cooler vs air conditioner. A heat pump is the other route people weigh; regional figures are in swamp cooler or heat pump by region.
Where this stops applying
- Other codes. The insulation and leakage figures are the 2021 IECC as New Mexico adopted it. Other states and cities adopt their own editions and amendments, so check what your building department enforces before relying on the 4.0 CFM figure.
- Ducts inside the envelope. Where all ducts and the air handler are inside the thermal envelope, the limit is 8.0 CFM rather than 4.0, and R403.3.1's rule for ducts outside conditioned space does not apply.
- Furnace ducts already in the house. If the home also has a furnace with its own supply and return ducts, that is a separate system with a return already built, and this page's arithmetic about the cooler drop does not apply to it.
Frequently asked questions
Are swamp cooler ducts too big for central air?
They are bigger than needed, not too big to use. A 17-3/4 in cooler drop carries a 3 ton system's 1,200 CFM at about 550 fpm, slow and quiet. The drop works as a supply trunk if it is sealed and insulated; what the house is missing is a return.
Do I need return air ducts to convert from a swamp cooler to AC?
Yes. A refrigerated system recirculates house air through the coil, so it needs a ducted return with a filter. GE's packaged unit manual says a closed return air duct system shall be used, and the 2021 IECC bars using framing cavities as ducts or plenums.
Can I put a rooftop AC unit where my swamp cooler was?
Not on the old roof jack. A cooler jack is one square opening. A downflow packaged unit sits on a curb about 44 in square or larger with separate supply and return openings, so the roof opening is reworked and the old jack hole is closed.
What insulation do AC ducts in the attic need?
Under the 2021 IECC, R-8 for supply and return ducts 3 in in diameter and larger located outside conditioned space, and R-6 for smaller ducts. That applies to ducts newly installed as part of the conversion.
How much does it cost to convert a swamp cooler house to refrigerated air?
One Albuquerque contractor says a conversion can start at $7,500 for many homes, before duct sealing or replacement, electrical panel upgrades or a second system. The return duct and any new attic ducts are where the duct part of that cost goes.
Sources and further reading
- 2021 International Energy Conservation Code, New Mexico edition, Chapter 4 [RE] Residential Energy Efficiency (R403.3 ducts, R403.7 equipment sizing, NM duct testing amendments), UpCodes
- 2021 International Energy Conservation Code, New Mexico edition, Chapter 5 [RE] Existing Buildings (R503.1 alterations), UpCodes
- AVPTC**14** Air Handlers Installation and Operating Instructions (IOA-4030, May 2018), Goodman Manufacturing, hosted by InspectApedia
- NP16GV Series Residential Packaged Units, Gas/Electric: Installation and Maintenance Instructions (507620G05, 07/2023), GE Appliances
- Airflow Test (Detailed Instructions), PTCS, Bonneville Power Administration
- Cooling Density Factor (formula and 5,000 ft value), CaptiveAire Systems
- Albuquerque's Source for Refrigerated Air Conditioning Services and Conversions, B. Carlson Heating and Air Conditioning
- Champion 3000, 4001 and 5000 DD/SD Specifications and Submittal Data, Champion Cooler (Essick Air), hosted by Appliance Factory Parts