Does Putting Ice in a Swamp Cooler Help?
Ice in a swamp cooler helps a little, for a short time, and only on portables. A 10 lb bag holds about 1,800 BTU: about 7 minutes of a 1,000 CFM cooler's output.
Short answer
A little, for a short time, and only on a portable. Each pound of ice absorbs 144 BTU as it melts and about 35 BTU more as it warms to the water temperature the pads hold. A 10 lb bag is about 1,800 BTU in total. A 1,000 CFM portable making a 15 F drop puts out about 16,200 BTU/h, so the bag adds about 11% for one hour, or the same as about 7 minutes of the cooler's own work. On a rooftop cooler it is about 1 minute.
Key takeaways
- Ice absorbs 144 BTU per pound as it melts, plus about 1 BTU per pound for each degree it warms. Melting and warming to a 67 F tank, a pound gives about 179 BTU.
- A 10 lb bag holds about 1,800 BTU. A 1,000 CFM portable at a 15 F drop delivers about 16,200 BTU/h, so the bag is worth about 11% for one hour, or about 1.7 F of extra drop.
- The gain lasts only while ice is melting. Once it is gone, the water over the pads heads back toward the wet bulb temperature, and the cooler works as before.
- Honeywell (CL30XC) and Hessaire (MC12) both sell ice as an option. Worked through, 5 lb is worth about 6 minutes of the Honeywell's output and about 4 minutes of the Hessaire's.
- On a 4,500 CFM rooftop cooler, the same 10 lb bag equals about 1 minute of output. It is not worth the climb.
On this page
- How a swamp cooler cools, and where ice fits in
- How much cooling a pound of ice holds
- What the cooler puts out in the same hour
- Two portables that sell ice as an option
- Rooftop coolers: skip it
- Ice on a humid day
- Ice in a swamp cooler: the numbers side by side
- The "50 F water" idea
- If you want to try it anyway
- What this answer does not cover
- Frequently asked questions
Putting ice in a swamp cooler helps a little, for a short time, and only on a portable. A 10 lb bag of ice soaks up about 1,800 BTU of heat in total. A 1,000 CFM portable cooler puts out about 16,200 BTU every hour. So the bag adds about 11% for one hour, or the same as about 7 minutes of the cooler's own work, and then it is gone. On a rooftop cooler, the same bag is worth about 1 minute.
That is not the answer the cold blast at start-up suggests, because the air does feel colder at first. This page shows where the extra cooling comes from, why it ends, and how much it is worth on two portables whose makers sell ice as an option.
How a swamp cooler cools, and where ice fits in
A swamp cooler (an evaporative cooler) pulls outdoor or room air through wet pads. Water evaporating from the pads takes heat out of the air, and that is where almost all of its cooling comes from. Each pound of water it evaporates absorbs about 1,060 BTU.
A pump lifts water from a tank at the bottom (the sump) to the top of the pads. What the air does not evaporate drips back into the tank and goes round again. That water behaves like the wet wick on a thermometer: it heads toward the wet bulb temperature, the coldest point evaporation can reach in that air. Whether you start with warm water or cold water, it ends up in the same place.
Ice adds a second, smaller kind of cooling. Water colder than the wet bulb chills the air by plain contact, the way a cold glass chills your hand. That extra lasts only while the water is below the wet bulb. When the ice is gone, the water drifts back up and the cooler works exactly as it did before it was added.
An ice compartment is a tray or box where you add ice so the pump can circulate the meltwater. It is a different thing from an ice-chest "air conditioner", a fan blowing over a cooler full of ice with no evaporation at all. The DIY swamp cooler page works through that design.
How much cooling a pound of ice holds
Ice absorbs heat in two steps.
- Melting. The latent heat of fusion of ice is 144 BTU per pound (ACHR News). The Engineering ToolBox lists 334 kJ/kg, which is the same 144 BTU/lb. It is the figure behind the AC "ton": melting one ton of ice in a day is 12,000 BTU/h, as how many tons is a swamp cooler explains.
- Warming. The meltwater starts at 32 F and warms to the tank's temperature, near the wet bulb. Liquid water takes about 1.0 BTU per pound for each degree F (Engineering ToolBox gives 1.008 at 32 F and 0.999 at 68 F).
Take a 95 F afternoon at 20% relative humidity. The wet bulb is about 67 F. Each pound of ice then gives 144 + 35 = 179 BTU. A 10 lb bag gives about 1,790 BTU, and a 5 lb load about 895 BTU.
Now compare that with a pound of water the cooler evaporates: about 1,060 BTU. A pound of ice is worth about one sixth of that, and once it melts, the cooler evaporates it like any other water. So a pound of ice in the tank gives about 17% more cooling than a pound of tap water, spread over the time it takes to evaporate.
What the cooler puts out in the same hour
The site uses one equation for a cooler's output:
On that 95 F afternoon, assume the portable's media gets a little over half way to the wet bulb. That is a 15 F drop, from 95 F to 80 F. A 1,000 CFM portable then delivers 1.08 x 1,000 x 15 = 16,200 BTU/h.
The 10 lb bag is 1,790 BTU. That is 11% of one hour's output, or put another way, it equals 1,790 / 16,200 x 60 = about 7 minutes of what the cooler does on its own. If it all went into one hour of air, it would add 1,790 / (1.08 x 1,000) = about 1.7 F to the drop. If it all went in over 20 minutes, it would add about 5 F for those 20 minutes. Either way, the total is the same 1,790 BTU.
That is why the first blast feels so good and why it fades. The extra cooling is real but small, and it arrives all at once at the start, while the ice is still melting.
Two portables that sell ice as an option
Makers do offer ice as an option. Honeywell's CL30XC manual shows an "Ice Compartment" on top of the unit and says: "If ice is available, you may add ice in the top ice compartment to enhance the cooling performance." Hessaire's MC12 guide has an "Ice Fill Option" with three steps: unlatch, tilt open, and "Add Ice To Water & Secure Latches".
| Model | Rated airflow | Water | Where the figures come from |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honeywell CL30XC | 525 CFM (900 m3/h) | 7.9 gal total capacity; 6 gal at the tank's Max mark | Manual spec table (water); Honeywell spec sheet (CFM, not in the manual) |
| Hessaire MC12 | 900 CFM | 2.8 gal tank | Manual cover label (CFM); hessaire.com spec list (tank, not in the manual) |
Neither maker gives a size for the ice load, so suppose 5 lb in each. That is about 895 BTU on the 95 F, 67 F wet bulb day, with the same 15 F drop.
Worked example: 5 lb of ice in a Honeywell CL30XC and a Hessaire MC12
Honeywell CL30XC, 525 CFM. Output: 1.08 x 525 x 15 = about 8,500 BTU/h. The ice: 895 BTU, which is 10.5% of an hour, or about 6 minutes of output. Spread over an hour, it adds 895 / (1.08 x 525) = about 1.6 F to the drop.
Hessaire MC12, 900 CFM. Output: 1.08 x 900 x 15 = about 14,600 BTU/h. The same ice is 6% of an hour, or about 4 minutes of output. Spread over an hour, it adds about 0.9 F.
Tank room. Ice floats, so 5 lb of it raises the water level by the same amount as 5 lb of water: 5 / 8.34 = 0.6 gal. On the MC12 that is a fifth of the 2.8 gal tank. Leave that space or the tank overfills as the ice goes in.
Run time. At a 15 F drop the CL30XC evaporates about 525 x 15 / 8,186 = 1.0 gal per hour, so a 6 gal fill lasts about 6 hours. The MC12 evaporates about 1.65 gal per hour, so 2.8 gal lasts about 1.7 hours. Ice does not shorten that. It melts into water the cooler then uses.
So the smaller the cooler, the more a fixed bag of ice counts. On the 525 CFM Honeywell it is a few minutes of noticeably colder air. On the 900 CFM Hessaire it is barely a degree for an hour.
Rooftop coolers: skip it
A whole-house cooler moves far more air than a portable. Take a 4,500 CFM rooftop unit at a 20 F drop: 1.08 x 4,500 x 20 = about 97,200 BTU/h. A 10 lb bag of ice is 1,790 BTU, which equals about 1 minute of output. Spread over an hour, it adds 1,790 / (1.08 x 4,500) = under 0.4 F to the drop.
The water side tells the same story. That cooler evaporates about 11 gallons an hour, and with bleed-off it uses about 137 gallons over a 10 hour day (see swamp cooler water usage). A 10 lb bag melts into 1.2 gallons. The float valve also keeps topping up the pan with supply water, so the cold meltwater is mixed away almost at once. Ice in a rooftop pan is not worth a trip up the ladder.
Ice on a humid day
Ice works the same in any weather, so its share grows when evaporation is weak. Take 90 F at 50% relative humidity, where the wet bulb is about 76 F, a gap of only 14 F. The same media now makes about a 7.5 F drop. A 1,000 CFM portable delivers 1.08 x 1,000 x 7.5 = about 8,100 BTU/h.
The 10 lb bag now gives 10 x (144 + 44) = about 1,880 BTU. That is about 23% of an hour, or 14 minutes of output. Spread over an hour, the extra drop is still about 1.7 F. So ice counts for more of a weak cooler's work, but it does not fix the real problem. On humid days the cooler is limited by the air, as do swamp coolers work in humidity explains.
Ice in a swamp cooler: the numbers side by side
Every row is worked above. The extra drop assumes the ice's cooling is spread evenly over one hour.
| Cooler and day | Output | Ice | Ice BTU | Equal to this much run time | Extra drop over 1 hour |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Honeywell CL30XC, 525 CFM, 95 F / 67 F wet bulb | 8,500 BTU/h | 5 lb | 895 | About 6 min | About 1.6 F |
| Hessaire MC12, 900 CFM, same day | 14,600 BTU/h | 5 lb | 895 | About 4 min | About 0.9 F |
| 1,000 CFM portable, same day | 16,200 BTU/h | 10 lb | 1,790 | About 7 min | About 1.7 F |
| 1,000 CFM portable, 90 F / 76 F wet bulb | 8,100 BTU/h | 10 lb | 1,880 | About 14 min | About 1.7 F |
| 4,500 CFM rooftop, 20 F drop | 97,200 BTU/h | 10 lb | 1,790 | About 1 min | Under 0.4 F |
The "50 F water" idea
You may read that a swamp cooler works best with water at a set temperature, such as 50 F. Neither the Honeywell nor the Hessaire manual gives any water temperature, and no water temperature could be held anyway. The pads pull the water toward the wet bulb, 67 F on the dry example day, whatever you start with. Keeping it at 50 F would mean adding ice nonstop. At 179 BTU a pound, matching even one extra degree on a 1,000 CFM portable takes about 6 lb of ice every hour.
If you want to try it anyway
- Use the compartment if there is one. Honeywell puts its ice compartment on top, with the water regulator inside it. Hessaire adds ice straight into the tank water.
- Leave room in the tank. Every pound of ice raises the water level as much as a pound of water.
- Frozen bottles or ice packs are cleaner. They give the same cooling per pound as loose ice, and they keep bag debris away from the pump. The pump not working page lists ice pack compartments as one way debris reaches the tank.
- Know where the ice came from. A freezer in the kitchen puts the ice's cooling, plus its own power, back into the house as heat. The DIY page covers that trade-off.
If your portable is not cooling enough, ice is the wrong fix. Check the pads are fully wet, open a window for relief air, and compare the supply air with the wet bulb, as swamp cooler not cooling walks through. If it is simply too small for the room, sizing portable and outdoor coolers gives the CFM you need.
What this answer does not cover
These figures are an upper limit, worked from published constants and maker specs, not from a test of either cooler. Some of the ice's cold goes into the tank walls and the room around the unit rather than the air stream. The 15 F drop is an assumption, not a figure either maker publishes. Your drop depends on your weather and media, and the cooling temperature calculator gives it for your conditions. The 1.08 constant is for sea-level air. Neither manual says how much ice the compartment holds, so check yours before buying a bag. And none of this applies to ice-chest coolers, which cool only by melting ice and are covered on the DIY page. For choosing a portable in the first place, see the portable evaporative cooler buying guide.
Frequently asked questions
How long does ice last in a swamp cooler?
That depends on how fast water runs over it, so no maker states a time. The total does not change, though. A 10 lb bag gives about 1,800 BTU whether it melts in 20 minutes or an hour. Spread over 20 minutes on a 1,000 CFM portable, that is about 5 F of extra drop. Spread over an hour, about 1.7 F.
Is ice or frozen water bottles better in a swamp cooler?
Per pound they give the same cooling: about 179 BTU each on a day with a 67 F wet bulb. Bottles or ice packs keep bag debris out of the tank and the pump, and you can refreeze them. Loose ice turns into water the cooler then evaporates, which adds a little run time.
What is the best water temperature for a swamp cooler?
There is no target to aim for. Neither the Honeywell nor the Hessaire manual gives one. The water running over the pads heads toward the outdoor wet bulb temperature on its own, whatever you start with. Cold water helps only until it warms to that point.
Does ice help a swamp cooler more on a humid day?
It makes up a bigger share, but it is still small. On a 90 F day at 50% humidity (wet bulb 76 F), a 1,000 CFM portable makes about a 7.5 F drop. A 10 lb bag then equals about 14 minutes of output instead of 7. The extra drop over an hour is still about 1.7 F.
Should I put ice in my rooftop swamp cooler?
No. A 4,500 CFM rooftop unit at a 20 F drop puts out about 97,000 BTU/h. A 10 lb bag equals about 1 minute of that. The float valve also keeps refilling the pan, so the cold water mixes into a steady supply of new water.
Sources and further reading
- Honeywell CL30XC Portable Evaporative Air Cooler user manual, JMATEK / Honeywell (hosted by Appliance Factory Parts)
- CL30XC Evaporative Air Cooler spec sheet, JMATEK / Honeywell Store
- MC12 Mobile Evaporative Cooler Use and Care Guide (manual_MC12_print_100923), Hessaire
- MC12V 900 CFM Mobile Cooler specifications, Hessaire
- Understanding What a Cooling Ton Means (John Tomczyk, March 4, 2021), ACHR News
- Latent Heat of Melting for some common Materials, The Engineering ToolBox
- Water: Specific Heat vs. Temperature, The Engineering ToolBox