8 Inch vs 12 Inch Swamp Cooler Media: Is the 12 Inch Worth It?
8 in vs 12 in rigid media compared from utility qualified lists and MasterCool's submittal: rated effectiveness by model, the 1.7 F gap, the airflow cost and which one gets the rebate.
Short answer
On a MasterCool, yes. The 12 in version is the same cabinet, motor and duct opening with media rated 90%, and it is the version that qualifies for PNM, El Paso Electric and Xcel premium rebates; the 8 in version has no rating on any of those lists. On a 100 F, 66 F wet bulb day the 12 in pad delivers about 69.4 F air, 1.7 F colder than an 85% pad, for about 4% less airflow. Depth alone is not the test, though: AeroCool's 8 in high density Pro media is rated 92%, above every 12 in model on Xcel's list.
Key takeaways
- Xcel Energy Colorado's qualified list rates MasterCool's 12 in models (C5112, C7112) and AeroCool's 12 in Trophy 4812 and 6812 at 90% media saturation effectiveness. MasterCool's 8 in 51 and 71 models appear only on the standard tier, with no rating.
- The rating belongs to the media, not the depth: AeroCool Pro coolers, which use 8 in media with a high density front half, are listed at 92 and 93%.
- Every point of effectiveness is worth 0.34 F on a 100 F, 66 F wet bulb day, so 90% against 85% is 1.7 F colder supply air.
- MasterCool's submittal shows the 12 in version moving 1 to 7% less air than the 8 in version on the same motor; on the 51 series at 0.3 in static it is 3,135 CFM against 3,260.
- Replacement 12 in MasterCool blocks list about $60 more than the 8 in block for the same cabinet; one rebate covers that gap several times over.
On this page
On a MasterCool, the 12 in media is worth it, and the reason is less the 1.7 F of colder air than the rebate. MasterCool's 12 in models are rated at 90% media saturation effectiveness on Xcel Energy's Colorado qualified list and appear on the PNM and El Paso Electric lists; the 8 in models carry no rating on any of them. Same cabinet width, same motor, same duct opening. But depth is not what the utilities actually test. AeroCool's 8 in high density Pro media is listed at 92%, higher than any 12 in cooler on the same list, so the question to ask about any cooler is what its media is rated, not how thick it is.
Rated effectiveness by model
The utility lists are the best evidence for this comparison: they print one effectiveness figure per cooler model, and they decide who gets paid. Xcel's premium tier requires "a media saturation effective rating of 85% or higher," El Paso Electric's New Mexico list says "Saturation Effectiveness ≥ 85%," and PNM's page says whole-house units qualify with "12-inch rigid media" while "units available with 8-inch media" do not.
| Cooler | Media depth | Xcel rating | PNM list | El Paso Electric NM list |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MasterCool C51, C71 (ADA/ASA 51, 71) | 8 in | Standard tier only, no rating | No | No |
| MasterCool C5112, C7112 (ADA/ASA 5112, 7112) | 12 in | 90% | Yes | Yes |
| Champion 4000 RLD4, 4000 CRLD4 | Not stated | 90% | Yes | No |
| AeroCool Trophy TD/TH 480, 680 | 8 in | "NA"; needs HD pad to qualify | No | No |
| AeroCool Trophy TD/TH 4812, 6812 | 12 in | 90% | Yes | Yes |
| AeroCool Pro PD/PH 480, 680 | 8 in, high density front half | 92% | Yes | Yes |
| AeroCool Pro PVD/PVH 680 | Not stated | 93% | Yes | No |
| Breezair EXT265 | Not stated | 85% | Yes | Yes |
| Breezair EXV155, EXV275, EXH170, EXH210 | Not stated | 86 to 87% | Yes | EXQ and EXVQ versions |
The media depths come from the model numbers (MasterCool and AeroCool put the 12 in their 12 in models' names, and Xcel files the Trophy 4812 and 6812 under a separate 12 in Trophy brand line) and from a supplier parts list that gives the Pro PH6800's media as 40 x 30 x 8 in with a "High density front half." Where no fetched source states a depth, the table says so.
Two things in that table settle the usual argument. First, the 12 in models on Xcel's list all rate 90%, not the 95% sometimes quoted for 12 in media. Second, the coolers rated above 90% are all AeroCool Pro models, and the one whose media is documented uses an 8 in high density pad. Denser 8 in media matches or beats ordinary 12 in media, and Xcel lets the 8 in Trophy qualify for the premium tier only once an HD pad is fitted. PNM's own list reflects the same thing: despite the 12-inch wording on its page, it includes the AeroCool Pro.
What 5 points of effectiveness buys
Effectiveness is the share of the gap between dry bulb and wet bulb that the pad closes, so its value scales with how dry the day is.
Worked example: the site's standard 100 F, 66 F day
The wet bulb depression is 34 F, so each point of effectiveness is worth 0.34 F. A 90% pad delivers 100 - 0.90 x 34 = 69.4 F. A pad at the 85% rebate floor delivers 100 - 0.85 x 34 = 71.1 F. The difference is 1.7 F. AeroCool Pro media at 92% delivers 68.7 F.
On a 92 F monsoon afternoon with a 74 F wet bulb, the depression is 18 F and the same 5 points are worth 0.9 F.
That 1.7 F is the smallest the gap can be for a MasterCool. Its 8 in models publish no rating, so 85% is the most they can be credited with on paper; if the real figure is lower, add 0.34 F per point. Run your own design day through the cooling temperature calculator or look up your city in the climate index.
The airflow cost of the thicker pad
Thicker media resists airflow more, and MasterCool's own submittal sheet puts a number on it. The C51 and C5112 share a 3/4 hp motor drawing 14.9 A at 115 V, a 16 in blower wheel and a 17-3/4 in duct opening; the C71 and C7112 share a 1 hp, 17.1 A motor, a 20 in wheel and a 19-3/4 in opening. The only differences are 4 in of cabinet depth and the media.
| Static pressure | C51 (8 in) | C5112 (12 in) | Change | C71 (8 in) | C7112 (12 in) | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 in | 3,788 | 3,606 | -4.8% | 5,024 | 4,941 | -1.7% |
| 0.2 in | 3,450 | 3,317 | -3.9% | 4,630 | 4,572 | -1.3% |
| 0.3 in | 3,260 | 3,135 | -3.8% | 4,450 | 4,394 | -1.3% |
| 0.4 in | 3,020 | 2,918 | -3.4% | 4,280 | 4,208 | -1.7% |
| 0.6 in | 2,570 | 2,379 | -7.4% | 3,900 | 3,749 | -3.9% |
So the 12 in cooler blows colder air but a little less of it. What the house feels is the product of the two.
Worked example: net cooling at 0.3 in static, house held at 80 F
Sensible cooling = 1.08 x CFM x (indoor temp - supply temp).
51 series: 12 in at 90%, 1.08 x 3,135 x (80 - 69.4) = about 35,900 BTU/h. 8 in credited with 85%, 1.08 x 3,260 x (80 - 71.1) = about 31,300 BTU/h. The 12 in cooler delivers about 15% more.
71 series: 1.08 x 4,394 x 10.6 = about 50,300 BTU/h against 1.08 x 4,450 x 8.9 = about 42,800 BTU/h, about 18% more.
To match the 12 in cooler, the 8 in version would need media rated about 89% on the 51 series and about 90% on the 71: in other words, as good as the 12 in pad.
The airflow loss is largest at high static pressure, so a cooler pushing into a long or undersized duct system gives back more of the gain. If your 51 series is working against 0.6 in, the 12 in version loses 7.4% of its air; check the drop and registers before blaming the pad. The motor size guide shows how fast CFM falls with static on other cabinets.
Weight, size and water
- Depth
- The 12 in cabinet is 4 in deeper: 49 in against 45 on the 51 series, 52 against 48 on the 71. Width (42 in) and height do not change, but the winter cover does; see what size cover for a swamp cooler.
- Weight
- Operating weight rises 30 lb on the 51 series (263 against 233 lb) and 37 lb on the 71 (306 against 269 lb), mostly water held in the thicker media. The roof load is worked out in how much does a swamp cooler weigh.
- Water
- Evaporation tracks CFM times temperature drop, and the 12 in cooler gains on one and loses on the other. On the standard day at 0.3 in static, the 51 series evaporates about 1.08 x 3,135 x 30.6 / 1,060 / 8.34 = 11.7 gal/h with 12 in media against 11.5 gal/h with 8 in media at 85%: about 2% more, before bleed-off. See swamp cooler water usage for the bleed-off share.
The money: rebate against pad price
The cooling gain is real but modest. The rebate is not. El Paso Electric pays $600 per unit in New Mexico on models from its list (its page advertises up to $1,000 per qualifying unit through December 15, 2026), PNM pays $400 on 2026 installs of listed whole-house units, and Xcel's list prints $675 for a single-duct premium cooler and $1,200 for one on three or more supply ducts, against $300 for a standard cooler. A MasterCool 8 in model gets none of the premium money in any of those territories. Current amounts and how to claim them are in swamp cooler rebates by utility.
| Cabinet | 8 in block | 12 in block | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50/51 series, 22-1/2 x 41-1/4 in face | GPAD802, $119.99 | GPAD121, $179.99 | $60 |
| 70/71 series, 29 x 41-1/4 in face | GPAD804, $139.99 | GPAD122, $199.99 | $60 |
A $60 difference per block, paid once every few seasons, is small next to a $400 to $1,000 rebate paid once. Media sizes and OEM part numbers for both depths are in what size pads does my swamp cooler take, and how many seasons a block lasts depends mostly on bleed-off and water quality.
Which to buy
| Situation | Choice |
|---|---|
| New MasterCool, any dry climate | 12 in (C5112 or C7112): rated, rebate eligible, 15 to 18% more cooling at 0.3 in |
| New MasterCool in a PNM, El Paso Electric or Xcel territory | 12 in; set the rebate against the dealer's price gap between the two versions |
| New AeroCool | Depth is not the deciding number: the 8 in HD Pro rates 92%, the 12 in Trophy 90%. Compare price and the list your utility uses |
| Existing 8 in cabinet | Stay with 8 in; the 12 in block does not fit. Replace it on time instead; see how often to replace cooler pads |
| Long or undersized ducts (0.5 in static or more) | 12 in still wins on a MasterCool, but by less; fix the duct restriction first |
| Humid summers, wet bulbs in the mid 70s | The gap shrinks below 1 F; buy on rebate and price |
Where this comparison stops applying
The ratings are what makers submitted to the utilities for new, fully wetted media, and Xcel's figures come from its 2020 list; a scaled or dry-streaked block of either depth runs well below them. The 8 in MasterCool rating is unpublished, so its 85% here is a ceiling, not a measurement. The airflow figures are MasterCool's alone: other cabinets will lose a different share of air to thicker media. The cooling arithmetic ignores heat picked up in the ducts, which trims both coolers by a similar amount. And for aspen coolers none of this applies; the step from aspen to any rigid media is far larger, as aspen vs rigid media shows.
Frequently asked questions
Can I put 12 in media in my 8 in MasterCool?
No. MasterCool builds the 12 in version as a separate model with a cabinet 4 in deeper (49 in instead of 45 on the 51 series, 52 instead of 48 on the 71). The 12 in block will not fit the 8 in frame.
Does 12 in media use more water?
Barely. It cools the air more but moves slightly less of it. On MasterCool's 51 series at 0.3 in static, a 90% 12 in pad evaporates about 11.7 gal/h on a 100 F, 66 F day against about 11.5 gal/h for an 85% 8 in pad, before bleed-off.
Does 12 in media need a bigger motor?
Not on a MasterCool. The C51 and C5112 both carry a 3/4 hp, 14.9 A (115 V) motor, and the C71 and C7112 both carry 1 hp, 17.1 A. The thicker media shows up as slightly lower CFM at each static pressure, not as a larger motor.
What does saturation effectiveness mean on a rebate list?
The share of the gap between outdoor dry bulb and wet bulb temperature that the media closes. At 90%, a pad facing 100 F air with a 66 F wet bulb delivers 100 - 0.90 x 34 = 69.4 F.
Is 12 in media worth it in a humid climate?
Less so. On a 92 F monsoon afternoon with a 74 F wet bulb, the gap between 90% and 85% media shrinks to 0.9 F, because the wet bulb depression is only 18 F.
Sources and further reading
- Colorado Evaporative Cooling Qualified Equipment List (2020 program year), Xcel Energy
- Evaporative cooling rebates (large and window-mounted units), PNM
- Qualified Advanced Evaporative Coolers ($400 Rebate for 2026 Installs), 7/21/2026, PNM
- Evaporative Central Cooler instant rebate, PNM (administered by CLEAResult)
- Evaporative Cooling: New Mexico residential energy rebate, El Paso Electric
- Evaporative Cooler Eligibility List, Rev. 07/20/2026, El Paso Electric
- MasterCool AD/AS C51, C5112, C71 and C7112 Specifications and Submittal Data, Champion Cooler (hosted by Appliance Factory Parts)
- Aerocool Pro Series PH6800/1/2 parts breakdown list, Indoor Comfort Supply
- MasterCool by Champion 8 in pads GPAD802 and GPAD804, Indoor Comfort Supply
- Ultracool and Champion MasterCool 12 in pads GPAD121 and GPAD122, Indoor Comfort Supply