Swamp Cooler vs Whole House Fan for Dry Climates
A whole house fan works only when outdoor air is cooler than the house. July hours below 75 F, afternoon wet bulb and watts per CFM for 10 Western cities.
Short answer
It depends on how cool your nights get. A whole house fan only cools when the outdoor air is cooler than your house, so it works at night and early morning. A swamp cooler works at the afternoon peak. In July, Denver, Reno, Sacramento and Salt Lake City have 11 to 14 hours a day at or below 75 F, so a fan can carry the night. Phoenix and Las Vegas have less than one, so only the cooler does the job.
Key takeaways
- A whole house fan pulls cool outdoor air in through open windows and pushes warm house air out through the attic. It can only cool when the outdoor air is cooler than the house.
- Look at the night low, not the day-night swing. Phoenix swings 26 F in July but bottoms out near 82 F, so a fan has almost no hours. Sacramento swings 38 F and drops to 62 F.
- In NASA POWER data for July 2021 to 2025, Denver, Reno, Sacramento and Salt Lake City had 11 to 14 hours a day at or below 75 F. Phoenix, Las Vegas and Tucson had 0.2 to 2.3.
- Per CFM, a QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X uses 0.045 to 0.064 W. A 1/2 hp cooler on a Champion 4001 DD uses about 0.36 W, roughly six to eight times as much.
- California's code sizes whole house fans at 1.5 CFM per sq ft of floor area and 1 sq ft of attic net free vent area per 750 CFM. The 2 CFM and 375 CFM figures some sites quote are from the 2013 code.
On this page
- What a whole house fan is, and how it differs from a cooler
- Look at the night low, not the swing
- Ten cities in July: when each tool works
- Watts per CFM: the fan is far cheaper to run
- California's whole house fan rule: 1.5 CFM per sq ft
- Running both: fan at night, cooler by day
- What this page does not cover
- Frequently asked questions
The answer depends on your nights. A whole house fan cools only when the air outside is cooler than the air inside. That means evening, night and early morning. A swamp cooler works at the afternoon peak, when the fan has nothing cool to bring in. So the question is how many hours your outdoor air spends below your indoor air, and how dry the air is at 3 pm.
In July, Denver, Reno, Sacramento and Salt Lake City spend 11 to 14 hours a day at or below 75 F. Phoenix and Las Vegas spend less than one. The table below gives all ten cities, then the watts, the code sizing and how to run both.
What a whole house fan is, and how it differs from a cooler
A whole house fan is a large fan mounted in the ceiling between the rooms and the attic. The California Energy Commission (CEC) describes it simply. It "draws cooler outdoor air through open windows, exhausts the warmer air into the attic, and then expels the air outside through attic vents." It does not cool the air at all. It swaps warm house air for cooler outdoor air. Run all night, it also cools the walls, floors and furniture, so the house starts the next day cooler.
A swamp cooler (evaporative cooler) also brings in outdoor air. But it pushes that air through wet pads first, and the evaporating water cools it. See how evaporative coolers work. Three terms decide which one works where you live:
- Diurnal swing
- The gap between the day's high and the night's low.
- Night low
- The coolest the outdoor air gets. A whole house fan can never pull the house below it.
- Wet bulb temperature
- The lowest temperature evaporating water can bring the air to. A cooler's supply air lands a few degrees above it. See wet bulb temperature explained.
The 0.88 is the efficiency of 8 in rigid media. It is the same figure the site's best climates page uses.
Look at the night low, not the swing
Dry climates are often said to suit whole house fans because they have big day-night swings. The swing is real, but it is the wrong number. Phoenix swings almost 26 F in July. Its average low is still about 82 F, warmer than most people keep a house. Sacramento swings 38 F and drops to about 62 F. The two cities have similar swings and opposite answers.
For the table, we counted the hours each day when the outdoor air was at or below 75 F. That is our cutoff, not a code value. It assumes a house sitting near 78 to 80 F at night. The fan needs outdoor air a few degrees below that to make the swap worth running. If you keep the house cooler, count fewer hours.
Ten cities in July: when each tool works
The figures are averages for July 2021 to 2025 from NASA's POWER hourly data. The afternoon wet bulb is taken at each day's hottest hour. We computed it from air temperature, dew point and surface pressure with PsychroLib, which follows the ASHRAE Handbook. We did not use POWER's own wet bulb field. In this data it equals the plain average of air temperature and dew point. On a Phoenix July afternoon that reads about 8 F too high (78.8 F against 70.5 F).
| City | High / low | Swing | Afternoon wet bulb | Cooler supply at the peak | Hours a day at or below 75 F | What does the work in July |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phoenix | 107.3 / 81.6 F | 25.7 F | 70.5 F | 74.9 F | 0.2 | Cooler only |
| Las Vegas | 108.0 / 79.7 F | 28.3 F | 67.1 F | 72.0 F | 0.6 | Cooler only |
| Tucson | 99.3 / 75.3 F | 24.1 F | 68.9 F | 72.6 F | 2.3 | Cooler only |
| Fresno | 106.7 / 71.0 F | 35.7 F | 67.0 F | 71.7 F | 4.7 | Both: fan before dawn, cooler the rest |
| Albuquerque | 94.2 / 67.4 F | 26.8 F | 63.3 F | 67.0 F | 8.5 | Both: fan before dawn, cooler the rest |
| Boise | 95.0 / 66.2 F | 28.8 F | 61.9 F | 65.8 F | 8.5 | Both: fan before dawn, cooler the rest |
| Salt Lake City | 90.2 / 63.3 F | 26.9 F | 59.7 F | 63.3 F | 10.7 | Fan all night, cooler for the afternoon |
| Sacramento | 99.7 / 61.8 F | 37.9 F | 64.5 F | 68.7 F | 11.3 | Fan all night, cooler for the afternoon |
| Reno | 90.3 / 59.5 F | 30.8 F | 57.0 F | 61.0 F | 13.0 | Fan all night, cooler for the afternoon |
| Denver | 87.5 / 58.4 F | 29.1 F | 58.5 F | 62.0 F | 13.8 | Fan all night, cooler for the afternoon |
The last column follows three rules.
- Under 3 cool hours a day: cooler only. Phoenix, Las Vegas and Tucson have too few cool hours for a fan to do much in July. June is a little better, at 2.4, 3.7 and 5.5 hours. In Phoenix the cooler also struggles. Its July supply air averages 74.9 F, and only 28% of July days came in at 74 F or less. That is monsoon humidity, covered in swamp coolers during monsoon season.
- About 4 to 9 cool hours: both, with the fan doing the small part. In Albuquerque and Boise the air drops below 75 F at about 10 or 11 pm and stays there until about 6 am. In Fresno the window is shorter, about 1 to 5 am. A fan can flush the house in those hours. The cooler carries the afternoon and the warm evening.
- 10 or more cool hours: the fan carries the night. In Salt Lake City, Sacramento, Reno and Denver, cool air arrives in the evening and lasts until morning. The cooler is needed only for the hottest part of the day. Its supply air there runs 61 to 69 F, which the site rates excellent.
The cooler's numbers hold up in every city but Phoenix. That is why the answer for most of the West is not either-or. It is which tool runs at which hour. For your own afternoon, try the cooling temperature calculator.
Watts per CFM: the fan is far cheaper to run
When the fan can work, it does the job on a fraction of the power. Sigler's spec sheet for the QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X lists 1,479 CFM at 66.7 W and 0.9 A. It also lists a second airflow, 1,040 CFM, measured to the HVI-916 test for California's code. The CEC requires a fan used for code compliance to be listed in the HVI Certified Products Directory. So 1,040 CFM is the figure the code counts.
For the cooler, take a Champion 4001 DD with its 1/2 hp motor. Champion's submittal sheet gives 3,064 CFM at 0.3 in of duct pressure. The site's generator sizing guide puts a 1/2 hp cooler's running load at about 1,090 W, pump included.
| Unit | Airflow | Power | Watts per CFM | Watts per 1,000 CFM |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X, rated | 1,479 CFM | 66.7 W | 0.045 | 45 |
| QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X, HVI-916 | 1,040 CFM | 66.7 W | 0.064 | 64 |
| Champion 4001 DD, 1/2 hp, at 0.3 in | 3,064 CFM | about 1,090 W | 0.36 | 356 |
Per CFM, the cooler uses six to eight times the power. That is not waste. It is the cost of making 100 F air into 69 F air. The fan cannot do that at any price. It only moves air that is already cool. Fuller cooler cost math is in swamp cooler operating cost.
California's whole house fan rule: 1.5 CFM per sq ft
California's energy code puts a whole house fan in its prescriptive package for new single-family homes in Climate Zones 8 through 14. The prescriptive package is the fixed checklist route to meeting the code. The reference cities for zones 12 and 13 are Sacramento and Fresno. It is not mandatory. A builder using the performance method can model the house without one. Homes of 500 sq ft and additions of 1,000 sq ft or less are exempt.
Two sets of numbers circulate. AirScape's blog quotes Section 150.1(c)12 as 2 CFM per sq ft and 1 sq ft of attic vent per 375 CFM. That was the 2013 code. The CEC's 2022 Single-Family Residential Compliance Manual states the current rule:
- Listed airflow of at least 1.5 CFM per sq ft of conditioned floor area.
- At least 1 sq ft of attic net free vent area per 750 CFM of rated airflow. Net free area is the open area of a vent that air can actually pass through.
- A one-page "How to operate your whole house fan" sheet for the homeowner.
The 2025 manual, in force since January 1, 2026, refers back to that 2022 section. The 2025 installation form still multiplies floor area by 1.5 and divides fan airflow by 750. The manual also asks for a back-drafting check where a gas appliance with an ordinary flue, or a wood or other solid-fuel stove, sits inside the house. A strong fan can pull flue gas back into the rooms.
Running both: fan at night, cooler by day
The two share one thing: the attic. A whole house fan dumps its air into the attic, and the attic vents let it out. A cooler vented through ceiling relief dampers does the same. The venting and relief air guide asks for 1 to 2 sq ft of attic net free area per 1,000 CFM of cooler air. Because the two run at different hours, size the attic vents for whichever needs more. Do not add the two together.
Worked example: a 1,500 sq ft house in Sacramento
Fan size. California's rule gives 1.5 x 1,500 = 2,250 CFM of listed airflow. Two Stealth Pro 1.5X fans list 2,080 CFM, which falls short. Three list 3,120. QuietCool's own 2 to 3 CFM per sq ft gives 3,000 to 4,500 CFM rated, and three fans rate 4,437. Both point to three fans, drawing 3 x 66.7 = 200 W.
Attic vents. The code minimum is 3,120 / 750 = 4.2 sq ft of net free area. QuietCool suggests 1.98 sq ft per fan, or 5.9 sq ft for three. A 3,064 CFM cooler needs 3.1 to 6.1 sq ft by the site's relief rule. About 6 sq ft of net free area serves both. If the vents carry insect screen, the CEC's table counts them at half their open area.
A July day. Sacramento drops below 75 F around 8 pm and stays there until about 7 am, about 11.3 hours. Open the windows, then run the fans. Three fans for 11.3 hours use about 2.3 kWh. The cooler on high for the same hours would use about 12.3 kWh. That is about 10 kWh saved a night, or about $1.50 at $0.15 per kWh. In the morning, shut the fans off and close the windows once outdoor air passes indoor air. When the house warms, start the cooler and open its relief windows or dampers. For 8 afternoon hours it uses about 8.7 kWh. Its supply air on an average July afternoon works out to 68.7 F.
Do not run them together. Three fans rate 4,437 CFM, more than the cooler's 3,064. The extra air has to come in through windows at the outdoor temperature, which is near 100 F at 3 pm.
To size the cooler itself, see how to size a swamp cooler. For the same choice with central air, see swamp cooler vs air conditioner.
What this page does not cover
The table shows outdoor air, not how warm your house gets. Whether a house can ride out a 90 F afternoon on night cooling alone depends on its insulation, shade and thermal mass. The CEC says fan results depend on climate, the building and "how much indoor temperature variation the occupant will tolerate." This page does not claim a fan alone is enough in any city. NASA POWER values are averages over a grid cell tens of miles wide, so they will not match one airport reading exactly. The 75 F cutoff is our choice. The cooler watts are for high speed, so low speed at night uses less. Every figure here covers June to August only. The page does not cover attic fans, smoke and pollen coming in through open windows, or how to wire either unit. Before cutting a ceiling for a fan, check for a gas appliance that could back-draft, and check that your attic vents meet the area above.
Frequently asked questions
Does a whole house fan work in Phoenix?
Not in midsummer. In NASA POWER data for July 2021 to 2025, Phoenix averaged 0.2 hours a day at or below 75 F, and the average low was about 82 F. June had 2.4 hours. A fan has very little cool air to bring in, so a swamp cooler or air conditioner has to do the work.
Can I run a whole house fan and a swamp cooler at the same time?
There is little point. The fan's job is to pull in cool outdoor air, and in the afternoon the outdoor air is hot. Three QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X fans are rated at 4,437 CFM, more than a 1/2 hp Champion 4001 DD delivers at 0.3 in. The extra air has to come in through open windows at the outdoor temperature. Run the fan at night and the cooler by day.
What size whole house fan do I need?
California's prescriptive rule asks for at least 1.5 CFM per sq ft of conditioned floor area, using the fan's listed airflow. QuietCool sizes its fans at 2 to 3 CFM per sq ft of its own rated airflow. For a 1,500 sq ft house, both point to three Stealth Pro 1.5X units.
How much attic venting does a whole house fan need?
California's rule is 1 sq ft of attic net free vent area per 750 CFM of the fan's listed airflow. QuietCool suggests 1.98 sq ft for its 1,479 CFM Stealth Pro 1.5X. The CEC also halves the value of vents covered with insect screen.
Does a whole house fan use less electricity than a swamp cooler?
Yes, by a wide margin. A QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X draws 66.7 W. A whole-house cooler with a 1/2 hp motor runs at about 1,090 W. But the fan only cools when the outdoor air is already cool. The cooler can make 100 F air into 69 F air in a Sacramento afternoon.
Sources and further reading
- 2022 Single-Family Residential Compliance Manual, Chapter 4: Building HVAC Requirements (May 2022), section 4.7.10 Ventilation Cooling, California Energy Commission
- 2025 Single-Family Residential Compliance Manual, Chapter 4: Building HVAC Requirements, California Energy Commission
- CEC-CF2R-MCH-02-E Whole House Fan, Certificate of Installation (2025 Single-Family Compliance, January 1, 2026), California Energy Commission
- JA2.1 Weather Data, Table 2-1: California Standard Climate Zone Summary, Energy Code Ace (California investor-owned utilities)
- Meeting California Title 24 2013 (June 18, 2014), AirScape Engineer's Blog
- QuietCool Stealth Pro 1.5X Whole House Fan with RF Controls, 1,479 CFM (QCSTLPRO15XRF), specifications, Russell Sigler, Inc.
- Champion 3000/4001/5000 DD and SD submittal sheet (motor amps and CFM by static pressure), Champion Cooler, via Appliance Factory Parts
- POWER hourly API, point data: T2M, T2MDEW, T2MWET, PS (example query: Phoenix, July 2025), NASA Langley Research Center, POWER Project
- POWER parameter definition: T2MWET, Wet Bulb Temperature at 2 Meters, NASA Langley Research Center, POWER Project
- PsychroLib: psychrometric functions after ASHRAE Handbook Fundamentals 2017, chapter 1, D. Meyer and D. Thevenard, GitHub