Is a Swamp Cooler Bad for a Guitar or Piano?
Taylor asks for 45 to 55% RH and a Steinway dealer page 45 to 70%. Cooler homes sit at 43 to 56% in June and 12 to 24% in winter. The swing is the risk.
Short answer
Usually not in a dry city. On June afternoons a vented cooler home in the desert West sits at about 43 to 56% RH, close to the 45 to 55% Taylor asks for and inside the 45 to 70% on a Steinway dealer's care page. The damage comes from the swing: the same homes fall to 12 to 24% when heated in winter, a drop of 31 to 48 points, and Steinway's magazine calls more than 30 points excessive. Monsoon afternoons in Phoenix and Tucson, near 70%, are the summer risk. Humidify in winter and keep the instrument out of the register's airstream.
Key takeaways
- Taylor builds its guitars at 46 to 47% RH and asks owners to keep them at 45 to 55%. A Steinway dealer's care page gives 45 to 70% for pianos, and Steinway's own magazine calls 45 to 50% the optimum.
- Modeled across six Western cities, a vented cooler home sits at 43 to 56% RH on June afternoons. That is in or within a point or two of Taylor's band in every city.
- Winter heating with no humidifier drops the same homes to 12 to 24%. The swing from summer to winter is 31 to 48 points, past the 30 points Steinway's magazine calls excessive.
- Phoenix and Tucson cooler afternoons average 70 to 71% in August. That is above Taylor's band and at the top of the Steinway dealer's range.
- An air-conditioned home in the same cities is drier in June, at 19 to 26%. Its swing is small, but the instrument sits below the makers' bands for most of the year.
On this page
- The terms the answer depends on
- What the makers ask for
- Cooler home humidity against the makers' bands
- Worked example: one guitar top in Albuquerque
- When the cooler is the problem
- What to do in a cooler home with a guitar or piano
- Why two answers circulate
- What these numbers do not cover
- Frequently asked questions
A swamp cooler is usually not bad for a guitar or piano in a dry city. On a June afternoon with the cooler running, a vented home in the desert West sits at about 43 to 56% relative humidity. Taylor asks owners to keep guitars at 45 to 55%. A Steinway dealer's care page gives 45 to 70% for pianos. The damage comes from the swing. Heated in winter with no humidifier, the same homes fall to 12 to 24%. Monsoon afternoons near 70% in Phoenix and Tucson are the summer risk.
This page sets the makers' bands against modeled humidity for six cities, walks one guitar through a year, and then lists what to do.
The terms the answer depends on
A swamp cooler is a direct evaporative cooler. A fan pulls outdoor air through wet pads, and the air leaves cooler and wetter. The how evaporative coolers work guide shows the parts.
Relative humidity (RH) is how much water vapor the air holds compared with the most it could hold at that temperature. A cooler raises RH. Heating air without adding water lowers it.
Wood in an instrument takes on or gives up water until it matches the air around it. The Wood Handbook calls that level the equilibrium moisture content (EMC). When EMC rises, wood swells across the grain. When it falls, wood shrinks. A guitar top or a piano soundboard is a thin, wide panel glued to braces, so it cannot move freely. That is why both makers care about the swing: how far humidity moves between the wettest and driest seasons.
What the makers ask for
Taylor (guitars). Taylor's humidifier page says its guitars "are built in a controlled environment where the relative humidity is 46 percent." Its dry guitar page gives 47% at 74 F. Either way, the target it gives owners is 45 to 55%. Taylor says a guitar not kept in that range "will be in danger of cracking." It lists bad action and buzzing, protruding fret ends, cracks, a sinking top and a lifting bridge as signs of dryness. It also says that "in areas prone to severe dryness and/or cold (such as heated homes), you must use a guitar-humidifying device."
Taylor covers the wet side too. It says a guitar usually gets over-humidified after "several weeks in an area where the humidity is very high (80-90%), or for several months where the humidity is medium-high (60-70%)."
Steinway (pianos). The care page on steinwaypianos.com, a Steinway & Sons dealer site, says "The most favorable environment for your piano is a relative humidity ranging between 45% and 70% and a constant temperature of approximately 20˚C." That is 68 F. It says a humidifier "should be used to control and regulate humidity" during the heating period. Steinway's own owners' magazine is narrower. It calls 45 to 50% "the optimum range for Steinway pianos." It says damage can occur above 75% RH. It also says that "a humidity fluctuation range in excess of 30 points on the relative humidity (RH) scale is excessive for the piano."
Yamaha (pianos). Yamaha's piano hub says "Yamaha recommends a range of 35-55% humidity, with 45% being optimal." Its Canadian care page says 40 to 45% is ideal. The makers agree on the middle, near 45%, and differ on how far either side is safe.
Cooler home humidity against the makers' bands
The city figures come from the site's hardwood floor model. It takes five years (2021 to 2025) of hourly NASA POWER weather for each city. Summer is afternoon hours from 11 am to 7 pm at 85 F or hotter, run through 85% media into a house at 78 F. Winter is December to February, heated to 68 F with no moisture added. RH comes from PsychroLib at each city's air pressure.
| City | June, cooler on | August, cooler on | Winter, heated to 68 F | Summer to winter swing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Denver | 43% (2 below) | 46% (in) | 12% | 34 points |
| Albuquerque | 47% (in) | 55% (in) | 15% | 40 points |
| Las Vegas | 52% (in) | 62% (7 over) | 19% | 43 points |
| El Paso | 53% (in) | 63% (8 over) | 18% | 45 points |
| Tucson | 53% (in) | 70% (15 over) | 22% | 48 points |
| Phoenix | 56% (1 over) | 71% (16 over) | 24% | 47 points |
The swing column is the wetter summer month minus winter. Three rulings come out of the table.
- June with a cooler: inside or at the edge of the bands. Every city sits within 2 points of Taylor's 45 to 55%. Against the Steinway dealer's 45 to 70%, only Denver is under, by 2 points.
- Winter: far below every band. Heated homes run 12 to 24%, under Yamaha's 35% floor and Taylor's 45%. The cooler is shut down by then, so this has nothing to do with it. Both Taylor and the Steinway dealer page call for a humidifier in the heating season.
- The swing is past Steinway's limit everywhere. Even using June alone, the drop to winter is 31 to 35 points. With August it is 34 to 48. Steinway's magazine calls more than 30 points excessive.
Air cooled to 78 F with no moisture added, the way refrigerated air behaves in a dry climate, gives 19 to 26% on June afternoons in the same model. That home swings far less, but it is dry in both seasons.
Worked example: one guitar top in Albuquerque
Worked example: how far a 16 in spruce top moves from June to January
Take an acoustic guitar with a Sitka spruce top that hangs on a living room wall in Albuquerque. Use a 16 in wide top, the width in Taylor's own example. Suppose the cooler runs on June afternoons and the house is heated to 68 F in winter with no humidifier.
June, cooler on: 47% RH at 78 F. The Wood Handbook's Equation 4-5 puts the wood at 8.7% EMC. Winter: 15% RH at 68 F gives 3.6%. That is a drop of 5.1 points.
Sitka spruce shrinks 4.3% across the growth rings (radial) and 7.5% along them (tangential), from Table 4-3. The winter EMC is under 6%, so the Handbook's Equation 13-4 applies. Worked through for the radial rate: 16 x 5.1 / (3,000 / 4.3 - 30 + 8.7) = about 0.12 in. At the tangential rate it is about 0.22 in. So the top tries to lose roughly 1/8 to 7/32 in of width, held back by its braces and glue joints.
Check that against Taylor. Its dry guitar page says a 16 in spruce top conditioned at 47% shrinks to 15.9 in at 30%, "almost 1/8 of an inch." The Handbook gives 0.06 to 0.11 in for that same step. Taylor's figure sits inside that range. Winter in Albuquerque takes the top further than Taylor's example does, because 15% is half of 30%.
Now move the guitar to Phoenix and use August. The wood goes from 13.3% to 5.3%, a drop of 8 points. The top then tries to move about 0.19 in at the radial rate and 0.33 in at the tangential rate.
Last, put the Albuquerque guitar in an air-conditioned house. June at 21% RH gives about 4.6% EMC. Winter gives 3.6%. The top moves only about 0.02 in. But it spends the summer at 21%, which is drier than the 30% Taylor uses as its warning case.
So the cooler home is the better summer home for the guitar, and the worse swing. The fix is not to give up the cooler. It is to bring winter up.
When the cooler is the problem
Monsoon afternoons in the low desert
Phoenix and Tucson cooler homes average 70 to 71% on August afternoons. That is well over Taylor's 55% and at the top of the Steinway dealer's 70%. It sits at the top of Taylor's "medium-high (60-70%)" range, which Taylor ties to over-humidifying over several months. July and August together are about two months of such afternoons. Nights with the pump off are drier, so the instrument sees less than the afternoon figure. Still, these are the weeks to watch a hygrometer. The monsoon season guide gives the dew point at which to switch the pump off.
A house with too little relief air
A cooler pushes damp air in, and it has to leave. With the windows shut, the house fills with supply air, which leaves the pads at roughly 70 to 85% RH. That passes Steinway's 75% damage line, and it can happen on a dry day. Open windows on the far side of the house, as the venting and relief air guide sizes them.
An instrument in the register's airstream
The air at a ceiling register is supply air, not room air. It is colder and wetter than the room reading. Yamaha says a good place for a piano stays away from "direct vents/radiators, etc. that cause warm or cool air to be blown near or on the piano." The Steinway dealer page says to keep pianos away from windows, outside doors and heating outlets. It also says sudden temperature changes must be avoided. A guitar on a stand under a register gets the same blast. Move it, or angle the register louvers away.
What to do in a cooler home with a guitar or piano
- Put a digital hygrometer next to the instrument, or inside the guitar case. Taylor says needle-style hygrometers fall out of calibration easily.
- In cooler season, aim for 45 to 55% at the instrument. Most dry-city June afternoons land there on their own. If the reading is in range, a water-based soundhole humidifier is not needed. Taylor says some guitars get over-humidified by owners who get carried away with them. Two-way packs that hold about 45 to 50% can stay in.
- On humid afternoons, open more relief or run fan-only until the reading drops below 55%. The too humid guide covers pad overflow and other causes of extra moisture.
- Humidify in winter. Taylor says a heated home needs a guitar-humidifying device. For a piano, the Steinway dealer page calls for a room humidifier in the heating season. A roof cooler cannot do this job, as the cooler as a humidifier page shows.
- Close the cooler for winter. An open, cold duct lets warm air out and dry outdoor air in. The winterizing guide covers the damper and cover.
- Check the swing. Note your highest summer reading and your lowest winter one. Keep the gap under 30 points, Steinway's line. Lifting winter from 15% to 40% in Albuquerque brings the June gap from 32 points to 7.
Why two answers circulate
One answer says swamp coolers ruin guitars and pianos. The other says they are good for them. Both point at real cases. A sealed-up house on a monsoon afternoon can push an instrument well past the makers' bands. A vented home in a dry June keeps it nearer 45% than refrigerated air does. Search results also repeat that Taylor warns against swamp coolers and that Steinway's warranty bars evaporative coolers. Neither claim appears on the Taylor and Steinway pages checked for this article. What those pages do say is to hold a band and to humidify in the heating season. Most answers leave out winter, when every home in these six cities falls far below the band.
What these numbers do not cover
The city figures are a model of a typical vented house, not a reading from yours. They assume 85% media, a house at 78 F and a cooler on during hot afternoons. Aspen pads, a warmer house or evening running will change them. NASA's data is for a grid square around each city. The winter figures leave out moisture from cooking, showers and people, so a lived-in house reads somewhat higher. The movement figures are for clear wood. A braced top or soundboard is held by its braces and glue joints, so the figures show how far the wood tries to move, not how far it does. They also do not say at what point a given instrument cracks. This page covers acoustic guitars and acoustic pianos, not solid-body electrics, digital pianos or other instruments. The pages quoted are care guidance, not warranty terms. Read your own maker's warranty, and take a crack, a lifting bridge or a sticking key to a repair technician rather than a hygrometer.
For how much water a cooler adds in the first place, see swamp coolers and indoor humidity. If a room has to stay dry all summer, indirect evaporative cooling adds little or no moisture to the house.
Frequently asked questions
What humidity should a guitar be kept at?
Taylor says 45 to 55% relative humidity. Its factory runs at 46 to 47%, and Taylor says a guitar kept outside 45 to 55% is in danger of cracking. A digital hygrometer in the room or case is the only way to know.
Is a swamp cooler too humid for a piano?
Not in a dry month. Cooler homes in the six cities modeled here average 43 to 56% on June afternoons, inside or near the 45 to 70% a Steinway dealer's care page gives. Steinway's magazine says damage can occur above 75%, which a vented home does not reach on average. A house run with the windows shut can, because air leaving the pads is about 70 to 85% RH.
Should I take the humidifier out of my guitar case in summer?
If a hygrometer reads 45 to 55% with the cooler running, a water-based soundhole humidifier is not needed then. Taylor says some guitars are over-humidified by owners who get carried away with soundhole humidifiers. Taylor describes two-way packs as holding about 45 to 50% by absorbing moisture as well as releasing it, so they can stay in.
Does Taylor say not to use a swamp cooler?
Not on the Taylor care pages checked for this article. Search results repeat that claim, but the humidifier, dry guitar and wet guitar pages on taylorguitars.com do not mention swamp or evaporative coolers. They give the 45 to 55% band, which a cooler home in a dry month mostly meets.
Is AC or a swamp cooler better for a guitar?
In a dry city in June, the cooler home is closer to Taylor's band: 43 to 56% against 19 to 26% for air cooled with no moisture added. The AC home swings less between seasons, but it is dry in both. Either way, Taylor says a heated home in winter needs a humidifying device.
Sources and further reading
- Using a Guitar Humidifier, Taylor Guitars
- Symptoms of a Dry Guitar, Taylor Guitars
- Symptoms of a Wet Guitar, Taylor Guitars
- Caring for Your Steinway, Steinway & Sons Dallas (steinwaypianos.com)
- Steinway Owners' Magazine: Troubled Waters (Inge Kjemtrup, Issue One 2013), Steinway & Sons
- Five Simple Steps for Maintaining Your Piano, Yamaha
- Caring for your Piano, Yamaha Canada
- Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material, FPL-GTR-282 (2021): Equation 4-5, Table 4-3, Equations 13-3 and 13-4, Table 13-5, USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory
- POWER hourly API: T2M, T2MDEW and PS, 2021 to 2025, for Phoenix, Tucson, Las Vegas, Albuquerque, El Paso and Denver, NASA Langley Research Center, POWER Project
- PsychroLib: psychrometric functions based on ASHRAE Handbook Fundamentals, PsychroLib project